Skip to content

James 1:19–20: Listening Before Advice in Discipleship

When someone shares a difficulty, we often start looking for something helpful to say. While preparing a Bible verse or a solution, we may miss what the person is actually telling us. Discipleship needs the sharing of Scripture and honest counsel. Scripture also teaches us when and how to speak. James 1:19–20 invites us to consider what it means to listen before offering advice.

An illustrative scene of listening attentively as another person speaks.
An illustrative scene of listening attentively as another person speaks. Illustration · AI-generated (Codex/ChatGPT)

Listening here is no promise to agree with every judgment another person makes. It does not mean covering up wrongdoing or enduring harm. It is a disciple’s obedience: laying down a hasty response before God, seeking to understand a person accurately, and then responding in keeping with his word. The direct Bible quotations in this article use the World English Bible (WEB).

An open Bible with a pen resting across its pages.
An open Bible with a pen resting across its pages. Photo: Ryk Neethling from Melbourne, Australia · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Receiving the word begins with examining how we listen

So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;

James 1:19, World English Bible (WEB)

for the anger of man doesn’t produce the righteousness of God.

James 1:20, World English Bible (WEB)

If we detach these verses as a lesson in conversation skills, we miss their setting. James 1:18 says that God brought us forth by the word of truth. James 1:21 then urges us to put away wickedness and receive the implanted word with humility. James 1:22–25 warns against hearing the word without doing it. The swift hearing and slow speaking of James 1:19–20 therefore belong in the movement from receiving God’s word to living it.

We need not narrow the object of hearing in James 1:19 to one person. The following call to receive the word plainly shows the need to listen before God’s word. The same posture is needed in discipleship conversations. Someone who first listens before Scripture can also examine the speed of their certainty and reactions before another person.

James 1:26–27 points to the gap in a faith that does not restrain the tongue and speaks of caring for people in distress. How we listen and speak is more than an inward matter. It shows how we practice the word we have learned in our relationships.

Two women in conversation across a table.
Two women in conversation across a table. Photo: Christina Morillo · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Listening quickly means delaying our conclusion

Proverbs 18:13 warns against answering before hearing a matter. At times we decide on a cause and a remedy after only a sentence or two. Even advice with true content can then miss the situation in front of us. Listening first does not abandon counsel; it is a beginning for discerning what needs to be said now.

In a one-to-one discipleship meeting, give the other person time to describe what happened as they sought to live by Scripture during the past week. Rather than judging the state of their faith from the opening detail, you can ask what happened, how they understand it, and what help they need now. Briefly check that you have understood what they said. These questions are no fixed counseling formula; they are a way to restrain hasty judgment.

The same applies in a small group. If several people offer solutions as soon as someone mentions a difficult relationship, that person may never finish telling the story. A leader can pause the advice and ask whether more time to explain would help. Then read the passage together and distinguish what it actually says from the group’s guesses.

A small group reads Bibles together around a table.
A small group reads Bibles together around a table. Photo: WELSTech Podcast · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Speaking slowly does not set truth aside

Being slow to speak does not mean postponing needed correction indefinitely or affirming every wrong choice. Ephesians 4:15 teaches us to speak the truth in love, and Ephesians 4:29 calls for words that benefit and build up those who hear. Love and truth are not competing options. After listening, we should seek words grounded in Scripture that will truly help the person.

For example, when someone describes a conflict, a listener need not immediately decide who is at fault. Matthew 7:3–5 teaches us to examine our own fault before addressing another person’s. Having examined ourselves, we can ask honest questions instead of rushing to take sides or condemn. The passage does not forbid us ever to name wrongdoing; it warns against trying to correct someone else while failing to see ourselves clearly.

Galatians 6:1–2 calls us to restore someone caught in wrongdoing with gentleness while watching ourselves and bearing one another’s burdens. The goal of speaking rightly in discipleship is not to win an argument. It is to help another person walk before the word again, with someone beside them. At times reading the same passage together, leaving room for a question, or connecting someone with needed help may be better than a long explanation.

A quiet path under the shade of trees.
A quiet path under the shade of trees. Photo: Malcolm Neal · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Slow the rush of anger and be clear about safety

James 1:20 plainly says that human anger does not produce God’s righteousness. This warning is easy to overlook precisely when we think we are right. Even when another person’s words seem troubling or mistaken, raising our voice to overpower them is not a way to accomplish God’s will. When a reaction is growing fierce, it is better to pause before continuing and distinguish what we heard from what we assume.

Listening must never become a duty to remain in danger. Do not tell someone experiencing violence, threats, or coercion to endure more and keep talking. Take their account seriously and help them find safety and appropriate protection and support. We can listen to someone without agreeing with a wrong action.

Three people walk together on a park path.
Three people walk together on a park path. Photo: George Courtney · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

Try this at your next meeting

Spend the first few minutes of a discipleship meeting listening without advice. As one person describes what happened while trying to live by Scripture that week, the others listen to the end without deciding the conclusion halfway through. Ask a question to check what you heard, and then read James 1:18–27 together. Relate the passage’s teaching on hearing, speaking, anger, and doing the word to your situations, but do not present guesses beyond the text as God’s commands.

Next, you can ask whether the person needs prayer, time to study the passage together, practical help, or a connection to safer support. Agree on one help that is possible and listen again at the next meeting. If it did not happen, explore the difficulty and a next step together instead of keeping score. This sequence is neither a program prescribed by Scripture nor a guarantee that a relationship will be repaired. It is a small practice in hearing and doing the word.

When you listen to someone today, set aside your prepared answer for a moment. Remember that God has already called us through his word, and stand before James’s counsel to be swift to hear and slow to speak and anger. As we listen carefully, we can keep practicing discipleship that speaks truth in love and seeks needed help together.

References

Watch the video

Watch this Short on YouTube

Leave a Reply